Im not personally familiar with any of Hagelins work but Im sure theres some good physics in there. The weirdness of quantum mechanics is reserved for either very specially prepared configurations in the laboratory, or scales that are so small that quantum-mechanical effects are significant. Q: You do see that in some science-fiction shows for example, last season on "Fringe." ?Discovering the Endless Possibilities of Your Everyday Reality. Interspersed with the plot were interviews with various supposed scientists with something to say about quantum physics, consciousness, God, etc. As a series of scientists and scientist types take a wayward stab at explaining quantum theory -- it seems to involve being in two places at once -- "What the Bleep," which opens nationwide today . The comments focus primarily on a single theme: "We create our own reality." IE 11 is not supported. About. Amanda is a photographer, who seems to be highly skilled but not very successful professionally. William Arntz has referred to the film as "WTFDWK" in a message to the film's street team. Some credible researchers appear, including neurologist Andrew Newberg and physicist David Albert (Albert has since disassociated himself from the film, saying his views were misrepresented). Do We (K)now!? The pity of it is that there are fascinating conversations going on in the science-and-religion sphere. kazakore (kazakore) January 14, 2010, 6:30pm #10 "What the Bleep Do We Know?" is a trendy new movie that combines the worst elements of a snooze-worthy PBS documentary, a "change your mind, change your life" self-help book, and a Bugs. ft. indoor riding arena once used for horse training which was refurbished and floored . so much for no good or bad, that is unless it is convienent. The sub-atomic particles that make up the atoms that make up the rock are there too. (stylized as What t #$*! Moreover, assume that they want your money. Do We Know!? Gripping stuff, but nothing to do with our daily lives. Z. Knight and heavily features commentary from 'Ramtha', an ancient Atlantian general who is apparently speaking through Knight. Real news, real hope. 1. is god-awful. The film has been described as an example of quantum mysticism, and has been criticized for both misrepresenting science and containing pseudoscience. Now comes the audio edition of the book based on the mind-boggling movie that grossed $11 million in the U.S. alone. Then comes "Carl Sagan Meets Madame Blavatsky." The only problem with Andrew Newberg's statement is that it suggests our subconscious brains are doing really interesting stuff and we're somehow missing out; if only we could harness that other zillion gigabits or so we'd be masters of our destinies. A roommate of mine was interested in TM and I think it was he who introduced us. Filename F:\torrent\What the Bleep Do We Know_2CD\disc one\09 What the Bleep.wav Peak level 100.0 % Extraction speed 8.6 X Track quality 100.0 % Test CRC 2A67087E Copy CRC 2A67087E Accurately ripped (confidence 4) [55AC2A89] (AR v1) Copy OK Track 10 Filename F:\torrent\What the Bleep Do We Know_2CD\disc one\10 Circle the Sun.wav Peak level 100.0 % As the movie did, this book compels listeners to ask themselves Gre. In 1958 nasa started mapping the ocean and exploring it. There's also much to be said for the idea that divine is not so much a separate entity but is found in the interconnectedness of the universe, something both traditional religious believers and "spiritual but not" people often agree on, though semantics can get in the way. That sounds like magic. Film / What the #$*! I guess the difference between me and those other people is that I actually have some grasp on the concepts that the movie was trying to talk about. 4000 volunteers regularly meditated to achieve a 25% drop in violent crime by the end of summer. The article states that the domestic gross exceeded $10 million, described as not bad for a low-budget documentary, and that the DVD release attained even more significant success with over a million units shipped in the first six months following its release in March 2005. Cathleen Falsani, who must have been taking notes while I was staring gobsmacked at the screen, quotes the 35,year-old . A: Quantum mechanics is often quoted as the explanation for many things, because it's so weird that people latch onto it as a hope, to explain everything that they would like to believe about the universe. Quantum mechanics, the theoretical framework of contemporary physics, is a probability algorithm. The film "What the Bleep Do We Know?!" One has already been recognized: If we do carefully prepare quantum systems, and keep them isolated, we can perform quantum magic technologically potentially on scales that we haven't been able to do before. 4. But above a tiny size range, quantum properties collapse, and particles start to behave in the way described by classical physics - more like bowling balls than fuzzy clouds of "wave functions. Nobody does.". With Marlee Matlin, Elaine Hendrix, John Ross Bowie, Robert Bailey Jr.. A fictional photographer's quest to spiritually rediscover herself is interspersed with documentary footage of scientists and theologians discussing the philosophical aspects of quantum physics. Staff meetings are tedious enough give me a conscious mind with a decent filter device any day. The Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle argues that its impossible to track the momentum and position of a subatomic particle. The year's most unexpected indie hit in American cinemas - a film about quantum physics - is about to open here. She works as a free-lancer for an agency, where her boss is played by Barry Newman. They were showing us the pictures of the waves converging to a point a meditation trick and this picture had a caption explaining that the unified field theory has already been found. It's recognized as pedagogical exaggeration. So does classical physics. "What the bleep. This website uses cookies to I don't know how many times I've heard people say, "Oh, I love quantum mechanics because I'm really into meditation, or I love the spiritual benefits that it brings me." One should take seriously the danger that hes not the only one deluding himself. The general idea was that since quantum mechanics supposedly says that there isnt one reality, but an infinite number of possibilities, one just has to be enlightened to an awareness of this, and then you can make whatever you want happen. (Source: iStockphoto). Miceal Ledwith DO WE KNOW? They may applaud the central tenets of the movie, but not its disjointed narrative, clunky acting, bizarre thematic segues, and faux "facts." People tend to believe that the fact that a certain kind of research is pursued by sizable numbers of people with very good credentials is enough to mean it must be good research. For many years in the early-mid-eighties, the Maharishi was pushing N=8 supergravity as the unified field theory, I remember a colorful poster explaining how it agreed exactly with his philosophy that many people posted on their walls. That movie started its life as a small documentary about Spirit and Science, but grew in scope (and budget) and became What the BLEEP Do We Know!? [14] Amongst the assertions in the film that have been challenged are that water molecules can be influenced by thought (as popularized by Masaru Emoto), that meditation can reduce violent crime rates of a city,[15] and that quantum physics implies that "consciousness is the ground of all being." Right after the Velvet Revolution in 1989 (the collapse of the Czechoslovak communism), many new spiritual and other directions were trying to find their ways to the new free countries. Q: Why do you think that people have seized upon this? They are relevant because of the deliberateness on the part of the film makers to keep certain facts unknown (ironically, it is I making the unknown know) and misrepresent others. "Particles appear and disappear where do they go when they're not here? 2. Bleep raises thought-provoking questions about science and its relationship to spirituality and metaphysics. But when you hear about quantum mechanics and consciousness, you should assume the author is a crackpot unless proven otherwise. "But that's two leaps beyond what scientists believe to be true.". And it certainly doesn't depend on an observer to make this happen. Hidden Messages In Water Hidden Messages in . It demands a freedom of view and greatness of thought so far unknown, indeed, not even dreamed of since Copernicus. Wow, indeed! Having watched this travesty of a movie, any real scientist worth his quarks might be gun-shy about joining the debate. If I didnt know any better, I would have thought it was something straight out of a Cheech and Chong movie. In one experiment, people who were walking across a college campus were asked by a stranger for directions. In a corrupt, greed-fueled world, a powerful alchemist leads a Christ-like character and seven materialistic figures to the Holy Mountain,. What the Bleep Do We Know draws heavily on the role of the observer in quantum physics. If it were manifest, you could run at a wall a lot of times, and every now and then you'd spontaneously appear on the other side of the wall. The web makes all such things available today, so I can give you a Google link to a page about Maharishis unified field theory, http://www.worldpeaceendowment.org/invincibility/invincibility6.html. Unfortunately, it also completely misunderstands it. You can't bring good things to you by thinking about them. The Bleep in a Nutshell: 1. As one of the film's characters gushes early in the proceedings, 'The moment we acknowledge the quantum self, we say that somebody has become enlightened'. The narrative follows a fictional photographer, Amanda, through her emotional and existential journey of life. ", "What the Bleep Do We Know!? (It's all to do with photons of light from your measuring instrument hitting the poor electron and knocking it for six). They want suggestions, not formulas. Down The Rabbit Hole\". They don't go anywhere, Fred. This is an explanation to help understand what might be going on, but it is not part of the theory because it is not falsifiable: it cannot be tested in such a way that, if it were false, it would fail the test (without falsifying the whole of quantum mechanics, and therefore all the other interpretations too). Scientists in the physical realm also hypothesize that matter is solid (Wilson 5). During the resulting chat, two men carrying a wooden door passed between the stranger and the subjects. The quantum world does pervade everything around us, but as Richard Feynman liked to say, "Scientific creativity is imagination in a straitjacket." Even followers of spiritual traditions that believe in worldly illusion will have problems with "Bleep." contact customer service is a book of amazing science, and now the international bestselling book is available in paperback. You are free to comment as you wish. She's averse to churches (she married her husband in one, so they must be bad! Hambling says it is likely that both the Hughes account and the story told by Pert were exaggerations of the records left by Captain Cook and the botanist Joseph Banks. John Hagelin, PhD, describes a study he did in Washington in 1992. If it were manifest, you could run at a wall a lot of times, and every now and then you'd spontaneously appear on the other side of the wall. Featuring interviews with scientists and theologians, this compelling film thrusts the viewer into a world where science and spirituality intersect. Directors William Arntz, Betsy Chasse Starring Marlee Matlin, Elaine Hendrix, John Ross Bowie Genres Publishers Weekly What the Bleep Do We Know!? You can renew your subscription or (I haven't). He has stated in several venues that his views were totally misrepresented in the film. Around 650 million people watched the moment on television. You can begin to be skeptical that the speaker is somehow trying to use quantum mechanics to argue fundamentally that you can change the world by thinking about it. Right now they use a key that's based on the products of large prime numbers, and no computer could determine the prime factors in a time shorter than the age of the universe. !" is a radical departure from convention. and What the #$*! . What was new? Dr Candice Pert But no scientific discovery has proved so ripe for spiritual projection as the theories of quantum physics, replete with their quixotic qualities of uncertainty, simultaneity and parallelism." The experts start "proving" that humans create their own reality by getting too attached to certain brain chemicals. Featured individuals [ edit] The film features interview segments of: Blech. But when you get hit with so much information that's been edited to within a frame of its life, things get a bit confusing. : Down the Rabbit Hole: Directed by William Arntz, Betsy Chasse, Mark Vicente. But it's not true for the universe at large. Extreme quantum mechanics could be the name of the speciality of SF writer (and physicist) Greg Egan. It comes from the Heisenberg Uncertainty Principle, and it's about the limitations of trying to measure the position and momentum of subatomic particles this only applies to sub-atomic particlesa rock doesn't need you to bump into it to exist. "[3] It offers alternative spirituality views characteristic of New Age philosophy, including critiques of the competing claims of stewardship among traditional religions [viz., institutional Judaism, Christianity, and Islam] of universally recognized and accepted moral values. And wait-the human body is mostly water! Who believe, in all kinds of things(God maybe?). When a movie gets rave reviews as a mind-blowing flick about quantum physics, it's worth checking out. Here's an edited transcript: Cosmic Log: Every once in a while, you'll hear about something like "The Secret," or some other reference to quantum mechanics as explaining how you can change your universe, or even perhaps why it's in the realm of possibility that a globe-gobbling black hole could be created because "anything can happen" in quantum mechanics. We are connected to the world by many things: by light and sound and heat. Q: You do see that in some science . The flip side of that is that you can use quantum mechanics, again in specially prepared systems, to communicate in a way that will allow us to know when someone is eavesdropping. What the #$*! 6. Then we segue to a narrative starring Amanda (Marlee Maitlin), a wedding photographer who's bummed because her slimy husband cheated on her. What the Bleep Do We Know!? Some movies are so bad, they're funny. "[15], Bernie Hobbs, a science writer with ABC Science Online, explains why the film is incorrect about quantum physics and reality: "The observer effect of quantum physics isn't about people or reality. Dr. Jeffrey Satinover (psychiatrist, PhD candidate in physics), in What the Bleep Do We Know? Those points suggest that quantum-derived "possibilities" affect the wider world, that human thought is the ultimate arbiter of physical reality, and that by manipulating thought properly, people can achieve harmony and even shape the structure of matter. But that still doesn't mean that, at a global level, the weirdness of quantum mechanics is manifest. People latch onto their dreams, and they always try to match them to reality. "I create my own reality, says quantum physics," intones one expert, and the viewer could be lured to accept this as proof. Not everything is possible. They were spreading their methods of meditation but that was not the main thing that impressed me. That's not the case. Mark was born in Johannesburg, South Africa . Krauss has dealt with factual and fictional weirdness for decades as the author of "The Physics of Star Trek," as the head of Arizona State University's Origins Project, and as the author of a "Quantum Man," a soon-to-be-published biography of pioneering physicist Richard Feynman. The debate here is that we'll be able to use quantum mechanics to break codes, in particular to determine the big prime numbers that are at the basis of the security of your credit cards and your bank cards. It is true that quantum mechanics is extremely strange, and on extremely small scales for short times, all sorts of weird things happen. What the Bleep!? Categories conflate, confound, connect", "Our power is in our ability to decide - Can you? subscription. Only the Shaman knows, and we're about 500 years too late to ask him. Despite his caveats, he recommends that people see the film, stating: "I hope it develops into a cult movie in the UK as it has in the US. As the layers to her everyday experiences fall away insertions in the story with scientists, and philosophers and religious leaders . Gifted and talented kids: how do you nurture a curious mind. [5] Foreign gross added another $5 million for a worldwide gross of nearly $16 million. Some argue that the same quantum processes seen in the universe around us have an effect on consciousness as well, but physicist Lawrence Krauss says that's highly debatable. In the documentary segments of the film, interviewees discuss the roots and meaning of Amanda's experiences. Magician and skeptic James Randi, famous for debunking performers like Uri Geller, has offered his standard prize of $1 million cash money to Dr Emoto if he can get the same results when doing the water study this way. Thanks to Pylon Sentinel for pointing this out.A link to his Wikipedia page is here: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Fred_Alan_Wolf In fact, "you are God in the making," which explains why Shirley MacLaine is a Ramtha fan. Isnt that a bit like attacking algebra because of Serge Langs nutty ideas about HIV and AIDS? 1. improve functionality and performance. In the letter, the authors write: "the movie illustrates the uncertainty principle with a bouncing basketball being in several places at once. [8], In the Publishers Weekly article, publicist Linda Rienecker of New Page Books says that she sees the success as part of a wider phenomenon, stating "A large part of the population is seeking spiritual connections, and they have the whole world to choose from now". You can be accurate in one or the other, but not in both. According to Joo Magueijo, professor in theoretical physics at Imperial College, the film deliberately misquotes science. At some point I guess he updated it to string field theory and the version you provided a link for. For traditional Christians, God is God not because your brain is making him up, but because he is. There were many more, but I will leave them for others. If quantum physics baffled the late Dr. Feynman, one of its most brilliant explorers, then no one should feel embarrassed for failing to understand the subject. John Haglin Z. Knight and her pet dead guy Ramtha. When you hear the term "quantum consciousness," you should be suspicious. But what quantum mechanics doesn't change about the universe is, if you want to change things, you still have to do something. Now I don't have an automatic prejudice against 35,000-year-old warriors from Atlantis or the women who channel them. "Your mind can't tell the difference between what it sees and what it remembers" Dr Joseph Dispenza (Chiropractor ) in What the Bleep Do We Know? We're also connected to the universe by gravity, and we're connected to the planets by gravity. He claims that in over 5 hours of interviews he explained to the film makers why their concept of how Quantum Physics works has virtually no support in the scientific community. Dr Dispenza claims (correctly) in the movie that brain scans PET (Positron Emission Tomography) and Functional MRI (Magnetic Resonance Imaging) show that the same part of your brain lights up whether you're looking at something or just remembering it. These photos may well be art they're sure as hell not science. Everyone said that you have to see this movie! So I did. Ive not seen the movie, and dont intend to, but David Alberts book on Quantum Mechanics and Experience is one of the best things Ive read on the interpretation of QM. If it's true, no one's been able to measure it or see the effects. One other area where quantum mechanics works on a macroscopic scale is in superconductivity and superfluidity. There are lots of things in quantum mechanics that sound like magic. That's not always true, but it's often true. DVD (2005) Marlee Matlin, Arntz (DIR) cert 12 at the best online prices at eBay! "[5] The same article quotes Bill Pfau, Advertising Manager of Inner Traditions, as saying "More and more ideas from the New Age community have become accepted into the mainstream. Quantum physics tells us that reality isn't fixed subatomic particles only come into existence when they are observed and 2. Dr Joao Migueijo is reader in theoretical physics at Imperial College, London.What the Bleep Do We Know!? to someone you know: Awash in New Age theorizing, real world science and the intellectually unfathomable notion of quantum mechanics, What the 'Bleep' Do We Know!? Can the weirdness of quantum mechanics make you well, or make you wealthy? Hagelin was a grad student at Harvard when I was an undergrad and I met him when we were in the same quantum field theory class. [7], According to Publishers Weekly, the film was one of the sleeper hits of 2004, as "word-of-mouth and strategic marketing kept it in theaters for an entire year." Some ideas discussed in the film are: In the narrative segments of the film, Marlee Matlin portrays Amanda, a photographer who plays the role of everywoman as she experiences her life from startlingly new and different perspectives. And while I'm no quantum physicist, my yoga teacher a big fan of the movie was starting to sound like she was. Study Guide", "Teaching physics mysteries versus pseudoscience", "Review: What The Bleep Do We Know!? It's truly amazing that you can separate two elementary particles that were originally tied together, and often make a measurement of one particle that instantly affects the other, even if it's on Alpha Centauri. Beyond fear, beyond anger. It was one of the most important moments in history. [16], David Albert, a philosopher of physics who appears in the film, has accused the filmmakers of selectively editing his interview to make it appear that he endorses the film's thesis that quantum mechanics is linked with consciousness. - - [2]. And if you're a modern thinker you'll know for a fact that quantum physics is wacky stuff. Everything from the possibility of disappearing and reappearing, to the possibility of having strange new forms of communication. That's why we experience a classical world. But they add that the film shows quantum mysteries selectively to shore up metaphysical points. Cast. "The movie is saying that somehow we can all get together and, with our collective thought processes, we can influence the outcome" of physical events - be they life experiences or scientific. To some extent it could be, because memories and thoughts are stored at the molecular level, and at a molecular level quantum mechanics is significant. Unfortunately, it also completely misunderstands it. 8. To date, Dr Emoto has not taken up the challenge. 19802023 The Christian Science Monitor. Dr Emoto takes photos of crystals formed in freezing water. Consciousness must be involved. Producing, scripting, and co-directing the film, What the BLEEP went on to become a global phenomenon, with well over 100 million viewers experiencing the BLEEP. Everyone knows quantum mechanics is weird, so why not use that to justify it? Easton's 1897 Bible Dictionary. It demands a freedom of view and greatness of thought so far unknown, indeed, not even dreamed of since Copernicus. A: Of course it does. Hobbs further disputed the film's use of the ten percent of the brain myth. last of a series of columns written for Scientific American, Why great minds can't grasp consciousness. The observer can't be ignored." And if you really want to be friendly, ask me about "The Case forPluto.". With Alejandro Jodorowsky, Horacio Salinas, Zamira Saunders, Juan Ferrara. But we behave like classical objects for a reason: We're big, we have lots of particles, they interact. In reality, science is completely incidental to the film's conclusions. A lot of the propaganda from them was hilarious, especially whenever candidates attempted to hold public speeches and performing demonstrations of yogic flying. Q. On August 1, 2006 What the Bleep! HCI president Peter Vegso stated that in regard to this book, "What the Bleep is the quantum leap in the New Age world," and "by marrying science and spirituality, it is the foundation of future thought."[5]. Pingback: Not Even Wrong Blog Archive Down the Rabbit Hole. !" is a radical departure from convention. Since its release in April 2004, this independent film has become a cult hit, playing to packed houses and grossing over $7.5 . But she is right about us not seeing things in front of our eyes if we're not looking for them. But quantum mechanics, for better or worse, doesn't bring any more spiritual benefits than gravity does. [17] Eric Scerri in a review for Committee for Skeptical Inquiry dismisses it as "a hodgepodge of all kinds of crackpot nonsense," where "science [is] distorted and sensationalized". Adapted from "Ask the Everyday Scientist" with permission of the writer. While Amanda waits for a commuter train, she (and we) are shown the work of Japanese scientist Masaru Emoto, who has photographed water after exposing it to different emotions. Somehow the main character of the movie was learning these amazing facts about quantum physics, and this then helps her deal with her anxiety attacks, bad body image and sex addiction (the film really goes off the rails in a bizarre scene where she is the photographer at a wedding party that turns into a grotesque kind of orgy). During our current Covid19 pandemic, this collection is highly relevant to a world still seeking novel answers to the human condition and also drawn to old theories long ago debunked. They're coming into the marketplace hungry for direction, but they don't want some person who claims to have all the answers. Occasionally recalling a physics lesson, an acid trip, and a lost afternoon at a New Age bookstore, What The BLEEP Do We Know?! Update: More information at the end of the video description.Comment approval now removed. and of course the big guy himself, Ramtha. The Christian Science Monitor has expired. 34 talking about this. You should be wary whenever you hear something like, "Quantum mechanics connects you with the universe" or "quantum mechanics unifies you with everything else."
Nyu Music Technology Portfolio, Bibaa Henry Nicole Smallman Dead Bodies, Articles W